Choosing the right eyebrow pencil color is key to creating well-defined, natural-looking brows that complement your hair color, skin tone, and overall makeup look. Here’s a guide to help you select the perfect shade.

1. Match Your Eyebrow Color, Not Your Hair Color

The general rule is to match your Eyebrow Pencil Color to your natural brow color, not necessarily your hair color. This ensures a more natural look, especially if your hair is dyed a different shade than your brows.

For Blonde Hair: “For blondes, i usually go for an eyebrow pencil that is 1–2 shades darker than your hair color. Blonde eyebrows are often very light, so using a slightly darker pencil adds definition without appearing harsh. Stick to cool-toned taupes, ash blonde, or light brown if your hair is platinum or ashy. Warmer blonde shades can opt for honey tones.”

For Brunette Hair: Match your pencil to your brow color, but opt for a shade that’s 1–2 shades lighter than your hair to avoid a too-dark or harsh look. For cool-toned brunettes, try ashy browns, while warmer brunettes can use chocolate browns.


For Black Hair: Opt for a dark brown or soft black pencil instead of true black. Pure black pencils can appear too harsh, while dark brown or charcoal black gives a softer, more natural finish.

For Red Hair: Redheads often have a mix of tones in their brows. Look for warm, red tone that match your natural brow tone rather than going too red. Avoid too-dark browns, which can appear unnatural.

2. Consider Your Skin Tone

our skin tone plays an essential role in selecting the right eyebrow pencil shade. The right color should complement your complexion and blend seamlessly with your overall look.

Fair Skin: Stick to soft, neutral tones like light brown or ash blonde. Avoid shades that are too dark or warm, as they can look unnatural against pale skin.

Medium Skin: Medium skin tones can pull off a variety of shades. Choose a medium brown pencil with either cool or warm undertones depending on your natural brow color and hair tone.


Olive Skin: Choose deeper, richer browns with ashy undertones for olive skin. Avoid reddish or overly warm browns, which may clash with the green undertones in your skin.

Dark Skin: Go for darker shades like deep brown or soft black. Avoid using true black, as it can look too bold. Instead, aim for shades that complement your skin’s natural warmth.

3. Undertone Matters for Eyebrow Pencil Color

Cool Undertones: If your hair and skin have cool undertones (ash blonde, cool brown, or black hair), opt for brow pencils with ashy or neutral tones. This helps avoid warmth that can look out of place.


Warm Undertones: If your hair and skin have warm undertones (golden blonde, red, or warm brown hair), a warmer eyebrow pencil with hints of gold or auburn will enhance your natural features.

4.Your Desired Look

Natural: For a natural look, choose a shade that closely matches your natural brow color. Use light strokes and blend well with a spoolie brush to avoid harsh lines.

Bold: If you want a more defined or bold brow, you can opt for a pencil that’s a shade darker than your natural brow color. Be sure to blend thoroughly to avoid a too-sharp or artificial look.

Through this article, when choosing an eyebrow pencil color, consider your hair color, skin tone, and overall makeup style. Try testing different colors in natural light to find the one that suits you best. You can also visit a cosmetics store to try out shades first. Remember to maintain a natural look and dimension in your brows, and take care of trimming and grooming. Now, go ahead and find your perfect eyebrow pencil color!